Why a data-first approach matters
Pre-IPO shares can deliver outsized outcomes, but they also carry information gaps, liquidity constraints, and governance risks. A repeatable, evidence-based process helps you avoid FOMO, price assets sensibly, and size positions so a single bet doesn’t derail the portfolio.
Compliance note: Nothing here is a recommendation. Use this as a framework alongside professional advice and SEBI guidelines.
The 5-step Pre-IPO decision framework
1) Define your investable universe (filter fast, then go deep)
- Stage & timing: Within ~12–36 months of a credible listing plan or strategic exit.
- Business model: Clear path to sustainable unit economics; recurring revenue or strong order book preferred.
- Ticket size & liquidity: Minimum cheque you can write without concentration risk; realistic secondary market float.
- Governance baseline: Reputed auditors, clean related-party history, and transparent disclosures.
2) Collect the right data (build a clean room of facts)
Create a single spreadsheet with these tabs and sources:
A. Business & financials
- Revenue mix, gross margin trends, opex intensity, working capital cycle, and capex needs.
- Unit economics: CAC, LTV, payback, cohort retention; for platforms, take rate, contribution margin.
- Quality of revenue: % recurring/contracted, churn, backlog, customer concentration.
- Cash profile: Operating cash flow, free cash flow, cash runway.
B. Market & moat
- TAM/SAM/SOM, category growth, pricing power.
- Switching costs, network effects, IP, regulatory tailwinds/overhangs.
C. Cap table & round dynamics
- Investor quality, preference stack (liquidation prefs), ESOP overhang, secondary vs primary mix.
- Seller profile in secondary (employees vs early investors) and reason for selling.
D. Governance & disclosures
- Board composition, independence, audit remarks, and related-party transactions.
- Legal/compliance flags; pending litigations.
E. Exit clarity
- DRHP/filing readiness, banker/merchant banker engagement, peer set mapping, approximate listing window.
- Alternative exit: Strategic sale, buyback, or extended private rounds.
3) Sanity-check valuation (evidence over excitement)
Use multiple lenses; don’t rely on a single lens.
A. Public comps (domestic & global)
- EV/Revenue, EV/EBITDA, P/E (if profitable), P/B (asset heavy), Price/Sales (early-growth).
- Adjust for growth, margin profile, cyclicality, and regulatory risk.
B. Private round triangulation
- Compare your secondary purchase price with the last primary round (post-money), fully diluted shares, and liquidation preferences.
- If senior preferences exist, haircut your valuation to the equity value available to ordinary shareholders in downside cases.
C. Intrinsic checks
- Simplified DCF (scenario-based), unit-economics build-up, or cohort-driven lifetime value models.
Guardrails:
- Avoid paying IPO-plus multiples unless you have superior information on near-term inflection.
- Demand a margin of safety for illiquidity, information risk, and lock-in.
4) Underwrite risks explicitly (and write them down)
Make a “pre-mortem” of what can go wrong:
- Execution: Missed product releases, channel issues, and customer churn.
- Regulatory: License dependence, pricing caps, compliance costs.
- Financial: Bridge rounds at punitive terms, covenant breaches, cash burn spikes.
- Governance: Related-party leakage, aggressive accounting, opaque ESOP practices.
- Liquidity: Extended listing timelines, narrow secondary markets, or listing deferrals.
Attach probabilities and impact (High/Medium/Low) to each risk. Revisit monthly.
5) Size positions & plan exits (before you buy)
- Position sizing: Cap any single Pre-IPO name to a small, pre-defined % of your net worth/alternatives bucket; stagger entries over tranches.
- Exit map: Primary plan listing; Alternatives block trade, strategic sale, or holding through the first 2–4 quarters post-IPO if fundamentals are accelerating.
- Lock-in: Pre-IPO shareholder lock-ins apply as per SEBI ICDR and category; expect holding constraints for a period around listing.
- Tax: Unlisted equity tax treatment differs from listed; periods for long-term/short-term and applicable rates vary by residency. Consult a tax advisor.
A practical, data-backed scoring model
Use this 100-point rubric to rank opportunities. Set a minimum pass score (e.g., 70) and a hard fail if any red-flag item is triggered.
| Pillar | Metric (examples) | Score (0–20 each) | Notes |
| Business Quality | Gross margin trend, revenue concentration, pricing power, and customer retention | /20 | More weight to revenue quality |
| Unit Economics | CAC payback, LTV/CAC, cohort stability, contribution margin | /20 | SaaS/recurring > transactional |
| Financial Resilience | Cash runway, OCF/FCF trend, leverage, working capital | /20 | Prefer self-funded growth |
| Governance | Audit quality, board independence, RPT transparency, ESOP clarity | /20 | Any major governance flag = fail |
| Valuation & Terms | Vs. comps, prefs overhang, anti-dilution, exit clarity | /20 | Demand illiquidity discount |
Red-flag triggers (automatic fail): Unresolved auditor qualifications; opaque related-party transactions; repeated down-rounds with heavy prefs; material litigation likely to impair operations.
Data sources & hygiene for Indian investors
- Company filings & disclosures: MCA filings, annual reports, investor presentations (if available), DRHP/RHP drafts.
- Third-party checks: Credit rating reports (if any), sector regulator updates, industry data, app store rankings/site traffic (as proxies), and vendor/customer interviews.
- Triangle of truth: Cross-verify management claims → documents → independent data. If two points disagree, dig deeper before investing.
Risk management & portfolio construction
- Allocation bucket: Treat Pre-IPO as part of alternatives alongside AIF/PMS/special situations; avoid crowding equity beta.
- Correlation lens: Ensure the position improves your portfolio’s diversification, not just return potential.
- Process discipline: Use investment memos, approval checklists, and post-mortems for continuous improvement.
Sample investment memo outline
- Thesis in 3 bullets
- What must be true (quantified checkpoints)
- Data snapshot (last 12–24 months)
- Valuation vs comps (table)
- Key risks & mitigants
- Position size & exit plan (incl. lock-in)
- Decision: Pass / Watchlist / Proceed (with conditions)
Common pitfalls to avoid
- Paying IPO-like multiples without liquidity.
- Ignoring preference stacks that can subordinate ordinary shareholders.
- Overweighting narrative; underweighting cash conversion and unit economics.
- Treating grey-market activity as a signal of value.
- Inadequate documentation (term sheets, SPA/SHA clauses, transfer restrictions).
FAQs
1) What minimum holding period should I budget for Pre-IPO shares?
Assume multi-quarter to multi-year horizons. Also account for SEBI lock-ins applicable to pre-IPO shareholders at the time of listing; durations vary by category.
2) How do I value a company that’s not yet profitable?
Use revenue multiples adjusted for growth/margins, triangulated with unit economics and a conservative DCF. Apply an illiquidity discount and preference-stack haircut.
3) Are ESOP sellers a red flag?
Not automatically. But if large insider selling clusters are around flat fundamentals or pending risks, treat it as a caution signal and re-check your thesis.
4) Can I rely on grey-market premiums (GMP)?
No. GMP reflects short-term sentiment and logistics, not intrinsic value. Focus on fundamentals, terms, and exit clarity.
5) How should NRIs approach Pre-IPO investments?
Mind regulatory eligibility, documentation, and taxation across jurisdictions.
Conclusion
Pre-IPO investing rewards process over predictions. When you standardize data collection, insist on clean governance, and price risk realistically, you tilt the odds in your favour without chasing hype. Build your scorecard, write the memo, size positions prudently, and keep reviewing your assumptions as new facts emerge.
Invest smarter with Equentis Investech.
