Investing in unlisted shares can offer an opportunity to participate in a company’s growth before it enters the stock market. However, unlike listed shares, unlisted shares do not have a publicly available market price that investors can track every day. This makes it important to understand whether the asking price is reasonable before making an investment.
A company may have strong growth potential, a well-known brand or an attractive business model, but that does not automatically mean its shares are fairly priced. Investors need to look beyond the company’s popularity and evaluate its financial performance, assets, future prospects and overall valuation.
So, how do you calculate the fair value of unlisted shares? Let’s understand the different valuation methods and the key factors investors should consider before investing.
What Is the Fair Value of Unlisted Shares?
Fair value refers to the estimated price at which a share could be exchanged between a willing buyer and a willing seller under normal market conditions.
For unlisted companies, this value is generally determined through financial analysis and valuation methods rather than daily stock market trading.
For example, suppose an unlisted company has an estimated fair value of ₹500 per share, but an existing shareholder is offering those shares at ₹700. The difference does not automatically mean the shares are overpriced, but it does indicate that investors should examine the company’s financials and growth expectations before deciding.
Fair value helps investors understand what they may be paying for a company’s ownership and whether the investment price is supported by its fundamentals.
Why Is Calculating Fair Value Important Before Investing?
Unlisted shares do not have the same price transparency and liquidity as listed shares. Their quoted prices may vary depending on the seller, demand, available information and expectations about the company’s future.
Calculating fair value can help investors:
- Avoid overpaying: Understand whether the asking price is supported by the company’s financial performance.
- Evaluate business fundamentals: Examine revenue, profitability, assets and liabilities before investing.
- Compare investment opportunities: Assess whether one unlisted company offers better value than another.
- Understand growth expectations: Determine whether the current valuation already accounts for future business growth.
- Manage investment risk: Make more informed decisions when dealing with limited liquidity and information.
5 Methods to Calculate the Fair Value of Unlisted Shares
There is no single valuation method that works for every unlisted company. The appropriate approach depends on the company’s industry, financial position, business model and stage of growth.
Here are five commonly used methods.
1. Net Asset Value (NAV) Method
The Net Asset Value method estimates a company’s worth by calculating the difference between its total assets and total liabilities.
It is particularly useful for companies whose value is closely linked to their physical assets, investments or property holdings.
Formula:
Net Asset Value = Total Assets – Total Liabilities
To calculate the value per share:
Fair Value Per Share = Net Asset Value / Total Outstanding Shares
Example:
Suppose an unlisted company has:
- Total assets: ₹100 crore
- Total liabilities: ₹30 crore
- Outstanding shares: 10 lakh
Its net asset value would be ₹70 crore.
Therefore:
₹70 crore / 10 lakh shares = ₹700 per share.
Based on this method, the estimated value of each share is ₹700.
However, NAV may not fully capture a company’s brand value, intellectual property, customer relationships or future earning potential.
2. Price-to-Earnings (P/E) Method
The Price-to-Earnings method estimates a company’s value by comparing its earnings with the valuation of similar listed companies.
It is commonly used for profitable businesses with relatively stable earnings.
Formula:
Estimated Share Value = Earnings Per Share (EPS) × Industry P/E Ratio
Example:
Suppose an unlisted company has an earnings per share (EPS) of ₹25. Similar listed companies in its industry trade at an average P/E ratio of 20.
Its estimated share value would be:
₹25 × 20 = ₹500 per share.
This suggests that the company’s shares could be worth approximately ₹500 based on comparable market valuations.
However, investors should not blindly apply the P/E ratio of a listed company. Differences in business size, growth, profitability, governance and liquidity can influence the appropriate valuation multiple.
3. Discounted Cash Flow (DCF) Method
The Discounted Cash Flow method estimates a company’s value based on the cash it is expected to generate in the future.
The underlying principle is that money received in the future is worth less than money available today. Therefore, expected future cash flows are discounted to calculate their present value.
This method is useful for companies with predictable business models and reasonably reliable financial projections.
Basic Formula:
Present Value = Future Cash Flow / (1 + Discount Rate)^Number of Years
To estimate the company’s value, investors calculate the present value of projected cash flows over a specific period and add the present value of the terminal value.
Example:
Suppose a company is expected to generate ₹10 crore in free cash flow next year. If the applicable discount rate is 12%, the present value of that cash flow would be:
₹10 crore / 1.12 = Approximately ₹8.93 crore.
The same calculation is performed for future years. The resulting values are added together to estimate the company’s enterprise value, subject to adjustments for debt, cash and other relevant items.
The DCF method can provide a detailed valuation, but its accuracy depends heavily on the assumptions used for future revenue, expenses, cash flows and discount rates.
4. Comparable Company Analysis
Comparable Company Analysis estimates the value of an unlisted business by comparing it with similar listed companies.
Investors examine businesses operating in the same industry with comparable business models, growth prospects and financial characteristics.
Common valuation multiples include:
- Price-to-Earnings (P/E)
- Enterprise Value to EBITDA (EV/EBITDA)
- Price-to-Book Value (P/B)
- Enterprise Value to Sales (EV/Sales)
Example:
Suppose a listed company operating in the same industry has an EV/EBITDA multiple of 12. An unlisted company with an EBITDA of ₹20 crore could have an estimated enterprise value of:
₹20 crore × 12 = ₹240 crore.
However, this is only an initial estimate. Investors must account for differences in company size, debt, growth, profitability and liquidity before arriving at a reasonable equity valuation.
5. Precedent Transaction Method
The Precedent Transaction method estimates a company’s value by studying the prices paid in previous acquisitions or investments involving similar businesses.
For example, if a company in the same industry was acquired at a valuation of 15 times its EBITDA, that transaction may provide a useful reference point for valuing another business.
However, acquisition prices may include a control premium or strategic benefits that are not available to ordinary shareholders. Market conditions at the time of the transaction can also influence the valuation.
Therefore, investors should use relevant transactions rather than treating every acquisition price as a direct benchmark.
Key Factors to Check Before Investing in Unlisted Shares
Valuation methods provide a starting point, but investors should also examine the company’s overall financial and business position.
Here are some important factors to consider:
1. Revenue and Profit Growth
Check whether the company has consistently increased its revenue and profits over the past few years. Sustainable growth is generally more meaningful than a temporary increase in earnings.
2. Debt and Financial Obligations
Examine the company’s outstanding borrowings, interest payments and debt-to-equity ratio. High debt can increase financial risk and affect the value available to shareholders.
3. Industry Position and Competition
Understand the company’s position within its industry. Its competitive advantages, customer base, market share and ability to retain customers can influence its future performance.
4. Management Quality
Evaluate the experience, credibility and track record of the company’s promoters and management team. Corporate governance and transparent financial reporting are particularly important when public information is limited.
5. Future Growth Potential
Consider whether the company has realistic opportunities to expand its operations, enter new markets or introduce new products. Growth expectations should be supported by business fundamentals rather than speculation.
6. Liquidity and Exit Opportunities
Unlisted shares are generally harder to sell than listed shares. Even if the company’s valuation increases, finding a buyer at the expected price may take time. Investors should understand the available exit options before committing their money.
Fair Value vs. Market Price of Unlisted Shares
Fair value and market price are not necessarily the same.
Fair value is an estimate based on the company’s financial position, future prospects and applicable valuation methods. The market price is the amount at which buyers and sellers are currently willing to transact.
For unlisted shares, the quoted price may be influenced by demand, supply, the seller’s expectations, recent transactions and anticipated corporate events.
For example, an unlisted share may have an estimated fair value of ₹500, while sellers are quoting ₹650. This difference could reflect strong demand or expectations of future growth, but it could also indicate that the asking price is higher than what the company’s fundamentals justify.
Investors should compare the asking price with a reasonable valuation range rather than assuming that a higher quoted price indicates a better investment.
Common Mistakes to Avoid When Valuing Unlisted Shares
Investors can make costly mistakes when they rely on limited information or focus only on a company’s future potential.
Some common mistakes include:
- Following market hype: Investing because a company is popular or frequently discussed without checking its financial performance.
- Ignoring liquidity risk: Assuming that unlisted shares can be sold whenever required.
- Relying on a single valuation method: Using only P/E or NAV without considering other relevant valuation approaches.
- Overestimating future growth: Accepting optimistic financial projections without examining the assumptions behind them.
- Ignoring financial liabilities: Looking at revenue and assets without evaluating debt and other obligations.
- Comparing unrelated companies: Using valuation multiples from businesses that have different operating models or growth profiles.
A thorough evaluation should combine financial analysis, industry research, management assessment and an understanding of the risks involved.
Conclusion
Calculating the fair value of unlisted shares is an important step before investing. Methods such as NAV, P/E, DCF, Comparable Company Analysis and Precedent Transaction Analysis can help investors estimate what a company’s shares may be worth.
However, no valuation method guarantees that an investment will generate returns. The final assessment should account for the company’s financial health, growth prospects, management quality, liquidity and the price at which shares are available.
Before investing, take the time to understand the business rather than relying entirely on its popularity or expected listing prospects. A well-researched valuation can help you make more informed investment decisions and avoid paying more than a company’s fundamentals justify.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. How do I calculate the fair value of unlisted shares?
You can estimate the fair value of unlisted shares using methods such as Net Asset Value, Price-to-Earnings, Discounted Cash Flow, Comparable Company Analysis and Precedent Transaction Analysis. The choice of method depends on the company’s financial position and business model.
2. Which valuation method is best for unlisted shares?
There is no universally best method. NAV may be useful for asset-heavy businesses, P/E for profitable companies, and DCF for businesses with predictable future cash flows. Using multiple methods can provide a more balanced valuation.
3. Are unlisted shares always cheaper than listed shares?
No. Unlisted shares are not necessarily cheaper. Their prices depend on the company’s valuation, investor demand, financial performance and future growth expectations. Some unlisted shares may be priced at a premium.
4. Why is liquidity important when investing in unlisted shares?
Unlisted shares do not trade on regular stock exchanges. This means investors may have to wait to find a buyer and may not be able to sell their shares at the desired price or time.
5. Can the fair value of unlisted shares change over time?
Yes. Fair value can change as the company’s revenue, profitability, debt, business prospects and industry conditions evolve. New funding rounds, acquisitions and other corporate developments can also influence its valuation.
6. Should I invest in unlisted shares based only on their expected IPO?
No. An expected IPO does not guarantee a listing, a particular listing price or investment returns. Investors should evaluate the company’s fundamentals, valuation and risks independently before investing.