Introduction
When evaluating a Portfolio Management Services (PMS) portfolio, returns are often the first thing investors look at. A portfolio delivering 25% returns may appear more attractive than one generating 18%. However, higher returns do not necessarily mean better portfolio management or a more suitable investment.
A PMS portfolio needs to be evaluated on several parameters, including risk, consistency, investment strategy, portfolio concentration and performance across different market conditions. A portfolio that delivers exceptional returns during a bull market may struggle when markets turn volatile.
For investors, the objective should not simply be to identify the PMS portfolio with the highest returns. It should be to understand how those returns were generated, how much risk was involved and whether the investment approach aligns with their financial goals.
Here is how investors can evaluate a PMS portfolio beyond its headline returns.
1. Understand How the Returns Were Generated
The first step is to understand what contributed to the portfolio’s performance.
A PMS portfolio may generate high returns because of a few successful stock selections, favourable sector movements or a broader market rally. However, these factors do not necessarily indicate that the investment strategy will deliver similar results in the future.
Investors should examine the portfolio’s major contributors to returns. Check whether performance came from several stocks or was largely dependent on two or three high-performing investments.
It is also important to understand whether the portfolio manager followed the original investment strategy or benefited from temporary market opportunities.
A consistent investment process can provide more confidence than a portfolio that has delivered strong returns through a few concentrated bets.
2. Compare Performance Against the Right Benchmark
Headline returns become more meaningful when compared with an appropriate benchmark.
A PMS portfolio investing primarily in mid-cap companies should not be evaluated against a benchmark that represents large-cap stocks. Similarly, a strategy focused on small-cap opportunities should be compared with an appropriate small-cap benchmark.
The benchmark helps investors understand whether the portfolio manager has generated additional returns or simply benefited from broader market movements.
For example, consider two PMS portfolios:
- Portfolio A delivers 22% returns against a benchmark return of 18%.
- Portfolio B delivers 19% returns against a benchmark return of 12%.
Although Portfolio A has higher absolute returns, Portfolio B has delivered a larger relative outperformance.
Investors should also examine performance across different periods instead of relying on one favourable year. SEBI’s performance reporting framework requires PMS providers to disclose Time-Weighted Rate of Return (TWRR) alongside the selected benchmark when communicating investment approach performance.
This makes it important to examine comparable performance figures rather than relying entirely on marketing presentations.
3. Examine Risk and Maximum Drawdown
Returns explain how much a portfolio has gained, but they do not reveal how much risk an investor had to take to achieve those gains.
This is where maximum drawdown becomes important.
Maximum drawdown measures the largest percentage decline in a portfolio from its previous peak to its subsequent lowest point during a particular period.
For example, consider two PMS portfolios:
- Portfolio A generates 20% annualised returns but experiences a maximum drawdown of 30%.
- Portfolio B generates 17% annualised returns with a maximum drawdown of 12%.
Portfolio A has delivered higher returns, but investors would also have experienced a much deeper decline in its value.
A significant drawdown can be difficult to manage, particularly for investors who may need access to their capital or are uncomfortable with sharp fluctuations.
Investors should also examine how long the portfolio took to recover from its previous peak. A strategy that experiences frequent declines or takes several years to recover may require a higher level of risk tolerance.
4. Check Consistency Across Different Market Conditions
A PMS strategy should not be evaluated only on its performance during favourable market conditions.
Stock markets move through different phases, including bull markets, corrections, periods of consolidation and economic uncertainty. Each phase can affect investment strategies differently.
Investors should examine how the portfolio performed during:
- Strong bull markets.
- Market corrections and downturns.
- Periods of high volatility.
- Slow economic growth.
- Changes in interest rates and liquidity conditions.
For example, a portfolio heavily invested in small-cap stocks may perform exceptionally well during a market rally but experience sharper corrections when investor sentiment weakens.
Looking at rolling returns can also help investors understand consistency. Instead of examining returns from only one starting and ending date, rolling returns measure performance across multiple overlapping periods.
This provides a better understanding of whether the PMS strategy has delivered relatively consistent results or whether its performance depends heavily on a particular market phase.
5. Evaluate Portfolio Concentration and Sector Exposure
The number of stocks in a PMS portfolio and their respective weightages can significantly influence its risk profile.
Some PMS strategies follow a concentrated investment approach, holding a relatively small number of companies with high conviction. Others maintain a broader portfolio to spread exposure across different businesses and sectors.
Neither approach is automatically better. What matters is whether the level of concentration is supported by the portfolio manager’s investment philosophy and risk management process.
Investors should examine:
- The percentage of the portfolio allocated to its top five and top ten holdings.
- Exposure to individual sectors.
- Allocation towards large-cap, mid-cap and small-cap companies.
- Whether the portfolio is dependent on a particular industry.
- Whether multiple holdings have similar business or market risks.
For instance, a portfolio holding several companies from the banking and financial services sector may appear diversified because it has different stocks. However, these investments could still be exposed to similar economic and interest rate risks.
Understanding the underlying exposure helps investors identify risks that may not be immediately visible from the number of stocks held.
6. Understand the Investment Philosophy and Strategy
A PMS portfolio should reflect a clearly defined investment philosophy.
Some portfolio managers follow a value investing approach, identifying companies that they believe are trading below their intrinsic value. Others focus on growth-oriented businesses, quality companies, emerging sectors or special market opportunities.
Investors should understand what drives the portfolio manager’s stock selection and how investment decisions are made.
Some important questions to consider include:
- Does the strategy focus on long-term wealth creation or shorter-term opportunities?
- What financial and business parameters are considered before selecting a stock?
- How does the portfolio manager identify overvalued companies?
- What factors trigger a decision to exit an investment?
- Has the investment strategy changed over time?
A clearly defined investment philosophy helps investors understand what to expect from the portfolio across different market conditions.
It also helps determine whether the PMS approach aligns with their own investment horizon and risk tolerance.
7. Look at Portfolio Turnover and Trading Costs
Portfolio turnover indicates how frequently investments are bought and sold within a PMS portfolio.
A high portfolio turnover may suggest that the manager actively adjusts holdings based on changing market conditions, valuations or investment opportunities. A lower turnover may indicate a more long-term investment approach.
However, neither a high nor low turnover automatically indicates better portfolio management.
Frequent buying and selling can increase brokerage, transaction charges and other expenses. It may also create additional tax implications for investors, depending on the nature and timing of transactions.
Investors should understand why the portfolio manager makes frequent changes and whether these decisions contribute meaningfully to performance.
It is equally important to examine whether the portfolio’s returns justify the costs associated with managing it.
8. Calculate Returns After Fees and Expenses
The returns highlighted in a PMS presentation may not fully represent what an investor ultimately receives.
PMS investments involve management fees, performance fees and other applicable expenses. These costs can reduce the overall returns generated by the portfolio.
Investors should understand the complete fee structure before making a decision.
Some important aspects to examine include:
- Fixed management fees.
- Performance-based fees.
- Applicable hurdle rates.
- High-water mark provisions.
- Brokerage and transaction expenses.
- Applicable taxes and other charges.
For example, consider a PMS portfolio that generates 20% gross returns. If management fees and other expenses reduce the overall performance, the investor’s actual returns will be lower.
It is therefore important to compare performance figures on a consistent net-of-fees basis and understand how the fee arrangement works.
A portfolio delivering slightly lower gross returns may prove more attractive if its overall costs are lower and its risk profile is more suitable.
9. Assess the Portfolio Manager’s Track Record
The performance of a PMS strategy is closely connected to the people managing it.
Investors should examine the portfolio manager’s experience, investment background and ability to navigate different market conditions.
A strong historical track record is useful, but it is equally important to understand who was responsible for generating those results.
Consider the following factors:
- Experience of the lead portfolio manager.
- Stability of the investment management team.
- Previous experience managing similar investment strategies.
- Changes in the portfolio management team.
- Consistency in following the stated investment philosophy.
A change in the lead portfolio manager or investment team may affect how a strategy is managed. Investors should understand whether the existing investment process will continue or whether significant changes are expected.
The objective is to determine whether the historical performance reflects a repeatable investment process rather than the contribution of one individual or a temporary market opportunity.
10. Understand Liquidity and the Investment Horizon
Liquidity is another important factor that investors should consider before selecting a PMS portfolio.
Unlike some traditional investment products, PMS portfolios may have significant exposure to individual stocks that are not equally liquid. This can become particularly relevant when a strategy invests heavily in small-cap and mid-cap companies.
Investors should examine the liquidity of the underlying holdings and understand how easily these investments can be sold during unfavourable market conditions.
They should also review the portfolio’s investment horizon and exit-related conditions.
A strategy designed to generate returns over five to seven years may not be suitable for someone who expects to withdraw their capital within a year or two.
Understanding liquidity, investment horizon and exit conditions helps investors determine whether a PMS portfolio is compatible with their financial requirements.
11. Review Disclosures and Reporting Transparency
A PMS provider should offer sufficient information for investors to understand how their money is being managed.
Investors should review the portfolio manager’s disclosure document, periodic portfolio statements, fee structure and investment-related disclosures.
SEBI’s PMS framework includes requirements relating to performance reporting, investment risks, fees, related-party investments and other important disclosures.
Investors should also check whether the performance figures presented in marketing materials are consistent with the reported investment approach performance.
Some important things to examine include:
- Whether performance figures are reported using the appropriate methodology.
- Whether returns are presented alongside the selected benchmark.
- Whether investment risks are clearly disclosed.
- Whether changes in investment strategy are communicated.
- Whether related-party investments and potential conflicts of interest are disclosed.
Transparent reporting helps investors make informed decisions and understand the actual performance of their portfolios.
Final Thoughts
Evaluating a PMS portfolio requires looking beyond the returns displayed in a presentation or performance report.
A strategy generating impressive returns may also carry higher risks, greater portfolio concentration or additional costs. Similarly, a portfolio delivering relatively moderate returns may demonstrate better consistency, stronger risk management and a more disciplined investment approach.
Investors should therefore examine performance, benchmark comparisons, maximum drawdowns, portfolio concentration, investment philosophy, fees and management experience before selecting a PMS.
Ultimately, the objective is not to identify the portfolio that has delivered the highest returns in the past. It is to understand how those returns were generated and whether the underlying investment strategy is suitable for long-term wealth creation.
A well-evaluated PMS portfolio is one where investors understand not just how much they can potentially earn, but also the risks, costs and investment decisions involved in generating those returns.